Adult Social CareCareCare HomesCare ProvidersCare ResidentsCare StaffHealthHealthcareHospitalsNewsNHSNursing HomesSocial Care

Covid Inquiry Exposes Serious Failures in Pandemic Test and Trace Response

Government failure to establish an effective contact tracing system during the early stages of the Covid-19 pandemic contributed to unnecessary deaths and prolonged the need for restrictive measures, according to the latest report from the UK Covid-19 Inquiry.

The inquiry, chaired by Baroness Heather Hallett, has identified significant shortcomings in the UK’s preparedness and response to the pandemic, concluding that the country lacked the capacity to implement effective testing, contact tracing and isolation measures when Covid-19 first emerged in early 2020.

The findings have prompted Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice UK to call on the Government to commit funding to a permanent national testing and contact tracing infrastructure, alongside a timetable for introducing a UK-wide system capable of responding rapidly to future outbreaks.

The report highlights how the initial response left the country struggling to identify and contain infections. Community contact tracing was effectively suspended in March 2020, as testing capacity proved insufficient to keep pace with the spread of the virus.

Baroness Hallett said the UK had not developed the systems necessary to test, trace and isolate people on the scale required when the pandemic arrived. As a result, the virus spread extensively during the first months, with serious consequences for individuals, families and communities.

She also highlighted the wider human impact of the pandemic, including bereavement, prolonged separation from relatives, social isolation, deteriorating mental health and financial hardship.

The inquiry’s findings raise particular questions about the subsequent establishment of NHS Test and Trace in England, which was launched in May 2020 under the leadership of Baroness Dido Harding.

The programme, which reportedly cost approximately £25 billion in England, relied heavily on large private-sector contractors, including Serco and Sitel, to deliver its contact tracing operation.

Rather than initially building upon the established expertise of local authority public health departments and existing specialist teams, the national programme made extensive use of outsourced call centre staff, many of whom lacked specialist public health training.

Limited Effectiveness 

The effectiveness of the system was consequently limited. Inquiry evidence showed that in England only 42 per cent of identified close contacts were successfully reached in June 2020. This increased to 47 per cent in July before falling to 44 per cent in August.

The report contrasts this performance with Northern Ireland, where existing public health laboratories and specialist contact tracing personnel were used within a more locally coordinated system.

By June 2020, Northern Ireland’s approach had enabled 92 per cent of people who tested positive to be reached.

Although the inquiry recognised that England’s substantially larger population presented different logistical challenges, it highlighted the benefits of retaining established public health expertise and making effective use of local knowledge.

The involvement of local authorities in England was subsequently expanded as concerns grew about the limitations of the national arrangements.

By September 2020, the proportion of identified contacts successfully traced had risen to 74.7 per cent with the assistance of local teams.

Their work included using established community relationships, local knowledge and, where necessary, face-to-face visits to reach individuals who had not been contacted through the centralised system.

Baroness Harding acknowledged during the inquiry that involving local expertise at an earlier stage would have been preferable.

The Local Government Association also emphasised the contribution made by council public health teams, whose understanding of their communities helped them reach people missed by the national programme.

The inquiry heard further criticism of the decision to move away from established public health arrangements. Professor Philip Banfield, chair of the British Medical Association’s council, told the inquiry that local public health professionals had been equipped with the relevant expertise and experience to undertake contact tracing as a fundamental part of their work.

The report also considered evidence from international comparisons. Professor Anthony Costello, a global health expert at University College London, told the inquiry that a more effective suppression strategy, supported by extensive testing, contact tracing and financial assistance for people required to isolate, could potentially have prevented up to, or more than, 180,000 deaths in the UK.

South Korea was highlighted as an example of a country which had implemented a more extensive testing and tracing response.

The inquiry concluded that shortcomings in the UK’s approach contributed to the country having to rely repeatedly on more restrictive interventions, including national lockdowns and school closures, with substantial consequences for society.

According to Office for National Statistics figures, there were 81,795 registered deaths involving Covid-19 in England and Wales during 2020. In 73,766 of these cases, Covid-19 was recorded as the underlying cause of death.

Bereaved families demand action

A Bereaved Families for Justice spokesperson said: “The Covid Inquiry has once again exposed the lies and incompetence that left thousands of us grieving loved ones who should still be here.

“On 3 March 2020, Boris Johnson told us Britain had “fantastic testing systems” and was “extremely well prepared”. That was a lie. Nine days later, his government stopped community testing as the virus spread.

“The UK and South Korea developed a Covid test on the same day. By early March, South Korea had carried out five times as many tests. Ministers needed no hindsight to see what was possible. Yet they sidelined local public health teams and left people who needed to isolate choosing between protecting others and paying their bills.

“Those responsible for failures that cost lives should be stripped of any honours they hold. They have no place in public life. We fought for this Inquiry to hold them to account and to spare others the grief we live with. It now falls to the current government to listen to bereaved people and make sure this never happens again.

“We are still dangerously unprepared. Laboratories built during Covid have closed and equipment has been sold off. Ministers must fund a permanent testing network, give local teams the staff to trace outbreaks and make sure anyone asked to isolate can afford to stay home.

“No one else should have to sit through another inquiry into the death of someone they love and hear another promise that lessons will be learnt.

“Our loved ones paid with their lives for the last government’s failure to prepare. This government must act now, while it can still spare others that loss.

We cannot wait for another pandemic to rebuild the systems needed to protect us.”

 

Nescafe26Blue